FundingPips · Trustpilot
FundingPips: 13 Trustpilot reviewers in a day say accounts were breached, blocked, closed or suspended over news; 11 say not high-impact
4 receiptsTrustpilot ↗
⚡ Daily drop
Goat Funded Trader
Goat Funded Trader answered 90 of 103 Trustpilot reviews since Sept 5, yet 22 reviewers in that window say payouts were refused or held over alleged coordinated or copy trading, and none of its replies to them offers a payout.
- Goat Funded Trader answered 90 of 103 reviews since Sept 5; 22 say payouts were refused or held over alleged copy or coordinated trading
- At least 13 FundingPips reviewers on Sept 21 link a breached, blocked, closed or suspended account to news; at least 11 say not high-impact
- At least 9 reviewers say Lucid Trading banned them or closed accounts over a chargeback they dispute; none of their reviews has a reply
- Atmos Funded published a Trustpilot reply that opens with the line Revising a review reply to sound more genuine
- Hola Prime says it removed its 60% per-trade profit concentration rule, 70% per-trade margin cap and 3-minute stop-loss deadline
Still open Goat Funded Trader's replies say its coordinated trading findings rest on matching trades, IP-related connections and other account and trading data, and that it cannot disclose its detection methods or details of other accounts. Several traders say they were sent a report of matching trades, and they dispute it. Does the firm ever show a trader the evidence behind the IP and other grounds it names, and is any payout that reviewers say was refused over coordinated trading ever paid?
The Pulse
Direction of travel, not a verdict.Goat Funded TraderLosing
Traders keep reporting payouts refused or held over a coordinated or copy trading finding, and the firm answers most of them on the record without offering a payout.
FundingPipsLosing
Reviews posted on a single day report accounts breached, blocked, closed or suspended over news most of them say was not rated red or top impact, alongside more reports of accounts terminated or blocked over device matches.
Lucid TradingLosing
Traders describe bans or closures over a chargeback they dispute, most saying they never filed one, alongside separate bans or closures citing cross-user activity, some as a payout was due.
Hola PrimeGrowing
The firm says it removed three rules from every active challenge and funded account automatically, with nothing to buy or reset.
TopstepLosing
The firm answers nearly every five star review, many with the same stock lines, and almost none of its one star ones, and it answered none of the account closure or ban reports.
The5ersStable
Among the reviews pulled, every reply went to a four or five star review and none to a critical one, with all but one of the skipped complaints landing before its last logged reply.
Apex Trader FundingStable
Among the reviews pulled, its only replies were one template posted to eight positive reviews inside three minutes, with nothing to the purchase block reports.
TradeifyGrowing
Verified on-chain payouts rose more in dollars than at any other board firm with a PayoutJunction reading, and it opened a free to enter league with a seven figure pool.
Trade The PoolStable
A trader puts a payout refused as a terms breach at five figures, and a review reporting a frozen account went unanswered for days while positive reviews got replies.
Atmos FundedStable
A published reply opens with a line about revising it to sound more genuine.
Instant FundingStable
Every review in the window drew a reply, and some name the account and the exact breach margin.
Equity EdgeGrowing
Reviewers report payouts rejected or withheld, at least two of them citing an impulsive trading reason.
Moneta FundedStable
The firm answers most of its reviews individually rather than by template, including critical ones.
Goat Funded FuturesGrowing
A one phase plan with payouts every day and no consistency rule on the funded account went live on the firm's own page.
Funded Trading PlusStable
A pay on pass account puts the entry cost at a few dollars, with the balance due only when the trader passes.
For TradersGrowing
In the reviews pulled, the firm answers only its critical ones, reinstated one account and corrected a figure its support team had quoted.
Drama 🍿
Every claim ships with receipts. Heat = how loud, not how proven.Affiliate · 𝕏 · 3,720
Affiliate accuses peers of reselling prop-firm giveaway accounts instead of distributing them
No receipts filed yet𝕏 ↗
Goat Funded Trader · Trustpilot
Goat Funded Trader: 22 traders since Sept 5 say payouts were refused or held over alleged coordinated or copy trading, one over $9,000
4 receiptsTrustpilot ↗
Lucid Trading · Trustpilot
Lucid Trading: 10 Trustpilot reviewers say they were accused of a chargeback they dispute, and 9 say they were banned
4 receiptsTrustpilot ↗
Codes live that day
Tap a code to copy it. Expiries are what the firm published.🎁 Affiliate giveaways
Free accounts, running now.$5000 X 3 Account Giveaway@neehyeehwah · Goat Funded Trader · 𝕏 · 81.8K reach24h flash — no end date in post · Open post ↗3x $5k@justmendex · Blue Guardian · 𝕏 · 21K reach24h flash — no end date in post · Open post ↗4 x $10k Giveaway Alert@Slim_Oraro · AquaFunded · 𝕏 · 19.6K reach24h flash — no end date in post · Open post ↗
Also today
A firm in today's Drama can't appear here. Warning Atmos Funded Atmos Funded publishes a Trustpilot reply that opens with the line Revising a review reply to sound more genuine. The firm's Trustpilot account answered a five-star review on Sept 16 with a reply whose first line, sitting above the greeting, reads Revising a review reply to sound more genuine. 2 firms, published replies that open with a line about the reply itself Sep 22
Rules Apex Trader Funding says Legacy accounts are going away, about four weeks after bringing them back. Apex posted on Sept 21 that Legacy accounts are going away, with 90% off the first month, $80 resets and $125 performance-account activations while the offer lasts, and no retirement date given. $125 Legacy PA activation, $80 Legacy reset Sep 21
Rules Funded Trading Plus launches Activation Accounts: $4 starts a challenge and the activation fee falls due on a pass. The firm says $4 starts a $25K, $50K or $100K challenge, and a trader who passes then pays an activation fee before the funded account is issued. $4 to start, balance due on passing Sep 21
Rules Hola Prime removes three trading rules, including the 60% profit concentration rule. The firm's own video of Sept 15 and its X post of Sept 18 say the 60% per-trade profit concentration rule, the 70% margin limit per trade and the 3-minute stop-loss deadline are removed, applied automatically to every active challenge and funded account with nothing to buy or reset. 3 rules removed, applied automatically Sep 15
New challenge AquaFunded Futures AquaFunded Futures launches four account models with on-demand and daily payouts x.com ↗
Sep 15
New challenge BEM Funding BEM Funding launches a 200K account size on 1-Step challenges x.com ↗
Aug 27
Milestone My Funded Futures My Funded Futures reports payouts land in under one second for most traders myfundedfutures.com ↗
Aug 27
Platform Lark Funding Lark Funding ships Lark Base, paying monthly base income during drawdown larkfunding.com ↗
Aug 20
Platform Top One Futures Top One 2.0 ships — new dashboard, higher drawdowns and account caps toponefutures.com ↗
Aug 15
Platform City Traders Imperium CTI Academy opens free access, 281+ lessons beginner to funded x.com ↗
Aug 14
New challenge Lark Funding Lark Funding opens Golden Competition: 25 paid places, free entry, Sept 1-15 x.com ↗
Aug 12
New challenge The Trading Pit The Trading Pit launches CFD Instant accounts — $5K/$10K/$20K, no evaluation t.me ↗
Aug 12
👀 Watch
Tick one to clear it.Goat Funded Trader's replies say its coordinated trading findings rest on matching trades, IP-related connections and other account and trading data, and that it cannot disclose its detection methods or details of other accounts. Several traders say they were sent a report of matching trades, and they dispute it. Does the firm ever show a trader the evidence behind the IP and other grounds it names, and is any payout that reviewers say was refused over coordinated trading ever paid?Goat Funded Trader
Issue #219 published Prime X as having no risk rule and no mandatory stop loss. Its limited-time homepage banner counted down to Sept 14 and is absent from our partly loaded Sept 22 capture of the homepage, the firm's rules pages list no Prime X tab, and the 1-Step Prime funded account they show requires a stop loss on every trade. Is Prime X still on sale, and on which rules?Hola Prime
Atmos Funded published a reply that opens with a line about revising it to sound more genuine, and Ylos Trading one opening on a translation note. Does either firm say anything about it, and does either reply get edited?Atmos Funded
That's the whole brief.
This issue is archived. The board has re-scored since, and today's brief is at the top of the site.